10 Best Electric Spin Scrubber in Canada

Last updated on 19-07-2025

Advertising disclosure

Leebein Electric Spin Scrubber, Shower Scrubber with 4 Adjustable Angles and 8 Brush Heads, Electric Scrubber with Long Handle & Remote Controller, Cleaning Brush for Bathroom, Tub, Floor (Black)

Free Shipping

Why We Love It

Effortless deep cleaning capability.
Revolutionary remote control function.
Long-lasting fast charge tech.

Main Highlights

🛀🏻【Powerful Electric Spin Scrubber】Struggle with those stubborn stains, soap scum, and grout that are hard to clean in your Bathroom? Don't worry, Leebein YMG-820 electric spin scrubber specializes in deep cleaning of mold & dirt in the shower & bathroom, especially for bathtubs, sinks, tiles, and grout, as well as for floors, walls, kitchen, and glass.
🌀【4 Adjustable Anglese and 2 Spin Modes】Leebein YMG-820 spin scrubber has two 2 adjustable spin speeds(350RPM/450RMP) 4 adjustable angles (90°, 120°,150, 180°), which makes it perfect for tackling tough cleaning tasks in your bathroom, bathtub, stone tile floors, grout, grooves, and toilets.
👍【Remote Control Cleaning Brush 】The one and only remote control cordless cleaning brush in the market, allows you to adjust the speed or turn the machine on/off without bending or kneeling, saving your knees and back. Besides, you can also control the machine with the controller on the short handle.
⚡️【One Charge to Clean the Whole House】Adapted upgraded 2500mAh*2 battery and USB-C fast charge tech, Leebein electric bathroom scrubber fully charges in 2.5 hours which lasts 60-90 min, far enough to clean your entire house. Besides, you can check the remaining battery by the LED light on the machine.
💎【Durable Bristles, Anti-Scratch Brush Heads】Leebein YMG-820 electric spin scrubber includes 8 durable and recoverable brush heads for various scenarios. Dome brush for the tub; Flat brush for surfaces like tile floor, wall, and pool; corner brush is great for cleaning grout, faucets, and edges; cloth brush for wooden floor and furniture cleaning; sponge pad is for the window. A tip: please sprinkle hot water on the bristle if it gets bent, and it will be recovered.
👪【Excellent Quality, 2-Year Extended Protection Plan】We choose high-end materials and high-quality internal components to ensure our products have a long service life. We provide a 90-day worry-free refund and a 2-Year extended protection plan. Please don't hesitate to contact Leebein support team if you encounter any problems.

Leebein Electric Spin Scrubber, 2025 New Cordless Cleaning Brush Bathroom Scrubber, IPX7 Waterproof Shower Scrubber with 7 Brush Heads, Extendable Long Handle and 2 Speeds Scrubber for Bathtub Floor

Free Shipping

Why We Love It

Powerful motor for efficient cleaning.
Durable bristles tackle tough stains.
Lightweight design for easy handling.

Main Highlights

【Powerful Performance for Efficient Cleaning】Leebein electric spin scrubber is equipped with a powerful 30W motor, delivering two-speed modes—300RPM for daily cleaning and 400RPM for deep cleaning. Even under high pressure, it operates quietly with a noise level below 50 dB, offering a more comfortable cleaning experience.
【Durable Bristles and IPX7 Waterproof Protection】Made from high-quality PP bristles, Leebein spin scrubber easily tackles tough stains without scratching delicate surfaces. The IPX7 waterproof design allows you to rinse the brush heads directly under water, making cleaning even easier.
【Adjustable & Lightweight for Hard-to-Reach Areas】With an extendable stainless-steel handle that adjusts from 12 to 50 inches, this electric spin scrubber allows you to reach high or low spots without bending or kneeling. Weighing just 1 lb, it’s lightweight and easy to handle, even for children or seniors.
【Long Battery Life and Cordless Freedom】Leebein electric scrubber features a powerful rechargeable battery that provides up to 90 minutes of runtime after a quick 3-hour charge. Its cordless design ensures unrestricted movement while cleaning, making it perfect for bathrooms, floors, cars, and more.
【2-Year Quality Assurance】Leebein electric cleaning brush is committed to product quality; We promise to provide good products and services; If you have any questions, please feel free to contact Leebein support E-mail or visit our official web, we will resolve your issue within 24 hours.

YKYI Electric Spin Scrubber,Cordless Electric Cleaning Brush,Shower Scrubber with 8 Replaceable Brush Heads,Power Scrubber 2 Adjustable Speeds,Bathroom Brush with Long Handle for Bathtub,Tile,Floor

88% OffFree Shipping

Why We Love It

Cordless for ultimate convenience.
Speed settings for tailored cleaning.
Versatile for all cleaning tasks.

Main Highlights

Versatile Cleaning Solution：Are you frustrated with traditional cleaning methods? The YKYI bathroom scrubber electric offers you a revolutionary cleaning experience. Our cordless electric scrubber eliminates the bondage brought by traditional cleaning tools—it can be used anytime and anywhere. Use the electric scrubber for cleaning the bathroom, including tasks like electric floor scrubber jobs, and your cleaning work will not feel tiring, saving more than 1 hour compared to traditional methods.
Electric Spin Scrubber 2025 Upgraded：We’ve upgraded this power scrubber with 2 adjustable speeds (380/480RPM). Equipped with a 2500mAh battery, it works continuously for up to 90 minutes after a 4-hour fast charge via the Type-C port. Say goodbye to traditional manual cleaning and save your valuable time.
Meet Different Cleaning Needs：With IPX7 waterproof design, the package includes 8 replaceable brush heads to tackle various tasks easily. It also comes with a hook and storage bags for space-saving storage. This electric cleaning brush is designed for diverse surfaces: shower rooms, narrow corners, glass, bathroom tile scrubber-ready walls, cars, kitchens, bathtub scrubber-perfect tubs, and furniture—meeting most of your requirements.
Ergonomic Design：The detachable retractable stainless steel handle, adjustable from 12 to 43.3 cm, provides a comfortable grip for all heights. This shower brush long handle design lets you easily reach hard-to-reach places without bending or kneeling, making it waist-friendly—especially for elderly family members. Ditch traditional supplies and embrace this life-changing household essential.
After-sales Service：We have a professional team offering a 2-year warranty for your electric shower scrubber. During the period, free repair/replacement is provided for manufacturing/material defects. Our electric bathroom scrubbing brush makes an ideal family gift—perfect for loved ones!

Electric Spin Scrubber, Cordless Kitchen Brushes, Bathroom Shower Cleaner with 9 Brush Heads, 2H Power Dual Speed, Adjustable Extension Handle, IPX7 Waterproof for Cleaning Brush

6% Off

Why We Love It

Versatile with six brush options.
Powerful motor for deep cleaning.
Lightweight and adjustable handle.

Main Highlights

One Scrubber, Multiple Choices: Electric cleaning brush includes 6 detachable brushes, round brush for curved surface like bathtub and toilet; flat brush for tile floors and grouts; Corner brush for Corner gaps; Sponge brush for windows...More usage ways waiting for you to explore! Kitchen Brushes
Upgrade Electric Spin Scrubber: Equipped with a powerful 25W motor, which can operate firmly even with high pressure and the working noise is under 50 dB. It also has 2 working speeds: 320RPM for daily cleaning and 400RPM for deep clean, meeting all your different cleaning needs. Kitchen Brushes
Easily Adjustable, Extremely Light: This shower spin scrubber equipped with extendable stainless-steel handle which extends from 24.8 inches to 47.3 inches, easy to clean hard-reach places, without kneeling or bending over. Brush weighs only 1 lb, even kids can use it with ease.
Sturdy Bristles, IPX7 Waterproof: This scrubber’s bristle is made of durable PP material, which make sure to clean the stubborn stain easily but without scratching surfaces. The brush is highly sealed to protect damage from water, You can wash the brush head directly in the water. Notice: Do not use brushes under water.
Ultra long-lasting, Wireless Tethering: This cordless shower scrubber comes with a massive 3000 mAh battery, which can last continuously up to 120 mins after 3.5 hours fast charging. Cordless cleaning brush allows you to clean any corner of your home without being restricted.

Leebein Electric Spin Scrubber, Cordless Cleaning Brush with 8 Replaceable Brush Heads, Tub and Floor Tile Power Scrubber Dual Speed with Adjustable & Detachable Handle for Bathroom Cleaning

25% OffFree Shipping

Why We Love It

Various versatile cleaning heads.
Quick USB-C charging capability.
Adjustable extension for reach.

Main Highlights

【8 Versatile Brush Heads】Leebein electric spin scrubber includes 8 replaceable cleaning brushes for various scenarios. Flat brush for surfaces like tile floor, wall, and pool; corner brush is great for cleaning grout, faucets, edges; cloth brush for wooden floor and furniture cleaning; the sponge is for the window. Moreover, you can even polish and wax your car with those heads.
【Type-C Fast Charging & Battery Level Display】Thanks to the latest USB-C fast charge technology and battery level display function, you never need to worry about running out of power. It can provide 90 minutes of long-term work after only 3 hours of fast charging.
【12-54in Detachable & Adjustable Mop】Leebein shower scrubber helps you get rid of laborious household cleaning, put the telescopic extension rod on and it will allow you to adjust the length of the spin scrubber from 12 inches up to 54 inches, which can help you clean the hard-to-reach places without bending and kneeling. Saving your back and knees by saying goodbye to the traditional clean way.
【2 Speeds Control & IPX7 Waterproof 】Leebein brush set has 2 working speeds, ① Low Speed: 300RPM; ②High Speed: 400RPM; All you need to do is press the ON/OFF button once. The brush is highly sealed to prevent damage from water, you can wash it directly under the faucet. Notice: it can not be used under water.
【Excellent Quality, 2-Year Protection Plan for Free】We choose high-end materials and high-quality internal components to ensure our products have a long service life. We provide a 90-day worry-free refund and a 2-Year extended warranty for free. Please feel free to contact us if you encounter any problems. This spin scrubber will be the best gift you can give to your family.

Keimi Electric Spin Scrubber, New Full-Body IPX7 Waterproof Cordless Bathroom Scrubber with 8 Replaceable Heads, Upgraded Extension Handle, Shower Cleaning Brush for Bathtub, Tile, Floor

38% OffFree Shipping

Why We Love It

Fully waterproof for safety.
Dual speeds for efficiency.
Eight versatile brush heads.

Main Highlights

【Use Securely with Full Body IPX7 Waterproofing】Enjoy complete freedom while cleaning in damp environments with our fully IPX7 waterproof electric spin scrubber. Unlike others that only offer waterproofing at the brush head, our scrubber is fully protected from top to bottom, preventing rust and short-circuit issues for long-lasting durability.
【8 Multi-functional Brush Heads, Removes All Stubborn Stains】Our cordless shower scrubber offers 8 versatile replaceable brush heads, suitable for different scenarios. For example, cleaning concave areas like bathtubs and sinks, cleaning narrow and hard-to-reach areas like corners and gaps as well as cleaning grounds, glass, tile wall, car surface, wheel hub, car seat, furniture and stove. As for how to use the corresponding brush heads, please refer to the instructions and images for details.
【Dual Spin Speeds, Cut Your Cleaning Time in Half】Tackle any cleaning task with our electric spin cleaning brush's dual speed settings. Use the lower speed for regular cleaning and the higher speed for stubborn stains. Switching between modes is as simple as a click, ensuring efficient and effective cleaning every time. For best results on tough stains, pair with your favorite detergent.
【Effortless Cleaning with an Extendable Handle】Keimi bathroom scrubber features an extendable handle with 7 adjustable lengths, making it perfect for those with limited mobility or anyone who wants to avoid bending or kneeling. Let our electric scrubber handle the hard work, making cleaning easy and comfortable.
【User-Friendly Design for All Ages】Our grout cleaner is user-friendly with a one-button release for easy assembly and disassembly. Lightweight and easy to maneuver, it’s perfect for seniors and anyone who prefers hassle-free cleaning. Our customer service team is always available to assist you with any questions.
【Perfect Present for Any Occasion】Show your loved ones you care with a practical and ergonomic present. Our electric bathroom scrubber makes cleaning more comfortable, saving time and effort while protecting joints and muscles. Ideal for birthdays, housewarmings, or just because, it's a thoughtful present that keeps on giving.

Electric Spin Scrubber, Cordless Cleaning Brush with 5 Replaceable Brush Heads and 2H Power Dual Speed, Adjustable & Detachable Long Handle, Shower Scrubber for Bathroom Tub Tile Floor Car, White-CA.

88% OffFree Shipping

Why We Love It

Powerful motor, low noise.
Long battery life, cordless.
Adjustable, lightweight handle.

Main Highlights

One Scrubber, Multiple Choices: Electric cleaning brush includes 5 detachable brushes, flat brush for tile floors and grouts; round brush for curved surface like bathtub and toilet; Sponge brush for windows; Corner brush for Corner gaps...More usage ways waiting for you to explore!.
Upgrade Electric Spin Scrubber: Equipped with a powerful 25W motor, which has 2 working speeds: 400RPM for daily cleaning and 480RPM for deep clean. It also can operate firmly even with high pressure and the working noise is under 50 dB, meeting all your different cleaning needs.
Easily Adjustable, Extremely Light: This shower spin scrubber equipped with extendable stainless-steel handle which extends from 24.8 inches to 47.3 inches, without kneeling or bending over, easy to clean hard-reach places. Brush weighs only 1 lb, even kids can use it with ease.
Sturdy Bristles, IPX7 Waterproof: This scrubber’s bristle is made of durable PP material, which make sure to clean the stubborn stain easily but without scratching surfaces. You can wash the brush head directly in the water because this brush is highly sealed to protect damage from water. Notice: Do not use brushes under water.
Ultra long-lasting, Wireless Tethering: This cordless shower scrubber comes with a massive 3000 mAh battery, which can last continuously up to 2 hours after 3.5 hours fast charging. Cordless cleaning brush allows you to clean any corner of your home without being restricted.

Leebein Electric Spin Scrubber, Shower Scrubber with 4 Adjustable Angles and 8 Brush Heads, Electric Scrubber with Long Handle & Remote Controller, Cleaning Brush for Bathroom, Tub, Floor (White)

Free Shipping

Why We Love It

Remote control convenience.
Two adjustable spin speeds.
Durable, anti-scratch brush heads.

Main Highlights

🛀🏻【Powerful Electric Spin Scrubber】Struggle with those stubborn stains, soap scum, and grout that are hard to clean in your Bathroom? Don't worry, Leebein YMG-820 electric spin scrubber specializes in deep cleaning of mold & dirt in the shower & bathroom, especially for bathtubs, sinks, tiles, and grout, as well as for floors, walls, kitchen, and glass.
🌀【4 Adjustable Anglese and 2 Spin Modes】Leebein YMG-820 spin scrubber has two 2 adjustable spin speeds(350RPM/450RMP) 4 adjustable angles (90°, 120°,150, 180°), which makes it perfect for tackling tough cleaning tasks in your bathroom, bathtub, stone tile floors, grout, grooves, and toilets.
👍【Remote Control Cleaning Brush 】The one and only remote control cordless cleaning brush in the market, allows you to adjust the speed or turn the machine on/off without bending or kneeling, saving your knees and back. Besides, you can also control the machine with the controller on the short handle.
⚡️【One Charge to Clean the Whole House】Adapted upgraded 2500mAh*2 battery and USB-C fast charge tech, Leebein electric bathroom scrubber fully charges in 2.5 hours which lasts 60-90 min, far enough to clean your entire house. Besides, you can check the remaining battery by the LED light on the machine.
💎【Durable Bristles, Anti-Scratch Brush Heads】Leebein YMG-820 electric spin scrubber includes 8 durable and recoverable brush heads for various scenarios. Dome brush for the tub; Flat brush for surfaces like tile floor, wall, and pool; corner brush is great for cleaning grout, faucets, and edges; cloth brush for wooden floor and furniture cleaning; sponge pad is for the window. A tip: please sprinkle hot water on the bristle if it gets bent, and it will be recovered.
👪【Excellent Quality, 2-Year Extended Protection Plan】We choose high-end materials and high-quality internal components to ensure our products have a long service life. We provide a 90-day worry-free refund and a 2-Year extended protection plan. Please don't hesitate to contact Leebein support team if you encounter any problems.

PKBD Electric Spin Scrubber, 2025 Upgrade Waterproof Cordless Scrubber with 8 Replaceable Heads, Electric Quantity Digital Display, Three clean speeds with Retractable handle, for Bathtub, Tile, Floor

20% OffFree Shipping

Why We Love It

Versatile cleaning with detachable brushes.
Powerful motor with digital display.
Ergonomic design for easy use.

Main Highlights

【Multifunction Electric Spin Scrubber】Electric cleaning brush includes 8 detachable brushes, round brush for curved surface like bathtub and toilet;flat brush for tile floors and grouts; Corner brush for Corner gaps;Sponge brush for windows...More usage ways waiting for you to explore!
【2025 New Upgraded Version】 Equipped with a powerful 25W motor, which can operate firmly even with high pressure and the working noise is under 50 dB. It also has 3 working speeds, meeting all your different cleaning needs.At the same time, it is equipped with a high-definition battery digital display, so that you can easily keep track of the remaining power during the cleaning process.
【Retractable Handle for Easy Use】This shower spin scrubber equipped with extendable stainless-steel handle which extends from 24.8 inches to 47.3 inches, easy to clean hard-reach places, without kneeling or bending over. Brush weighs only 1 lb, even kids can use it with ease.
【Sturdy Bristles, Full Body Waterproof】 This bristle is made of durable PP material, which make sure to clean the stubborn stain easily but without scratching surfaces. The brush is highly sealed to protect damage from water, You can wash the brush head directly in the water. Notice: Do not use brushes under water.
【Ideal Gift Choice】Show your loved ones you care with a practical and ergonomic present. Our electric bathroom scrubber makes cleaning more comfortable, saving time and effort while protecting joints and muscles. Ideal gitfs for birthdays, housewarmings, Mother's Day...

Electric Spin Scrubber, [Adjustable Angle] Homtronics Cordless Electric Cleaning Brush with 8 Replaceable Brush Heads, Battery Display, 450r/min Speed, 50in Adjustable Long Handle for Bathroom

Free Shipping

Why We Love It

Adjustable and versatile cleaning tool.
Intelligent battery level display.
Long-lasting and rechargeable.

Main Highlights

【Adjustable Angle】The electric cleaning brush is adjustable from 15-50in with 4 adjustable angles (90°, 120°, 150, 180°). You do not have to climb up to the top of counters, chairs, or step ladders to reach above the cabinetry or doors. Or you can just use it without the extension handle, which can be easier to hold it. Supporting up to 50kg, the powerful motor scrubber powers through stubborn stains under pressure without interruption
【Intelligent Digital Display】Homtronics cordless electric scrub brush has a battery level display function, which can observe the battery status of the electric cleaning brush at any time.
【8 Replaceable Brushes & Hook Storage】 Homtronics power scrubber comes with 8 versatile brush heads, a Velcro holder and hook to meet your various cleaning needs. We have 8 replaceable cleaning brushes for various scenarios. Flat brush for surfaces like tile floor, wall and pool; corner brush is great for cleaning grout, faucets, edges; cloth brush for wooden floor and furniture cleaning; sponge is for window. Moreover, you can even polish and wax your car with those heads.
【Stronger Cleaning Power】 Compared with other electric spin scrubbers, Homtronics electric spin scrubber for bathroom is more powerful, it designed with 2 speed control modes: ① High Speed Mode: 450 r/min and ② Low Speed Mode: 350 r/min. You need to do is press the ON/OFF button once. We design 2 speed control modes which means a moderate and reasonable speed to ensure sewage will not splash randomly when cleaning. Enjoy the housework now.
【120mins Work Time- Cordless Rechargeable】 Equipped with 2*2500mAh large capacity battery, our cordless electric floor scrubber can provide 120mins long time work after 2.5 hours Type-C fast charging (adapter not included). The cordless design ensures that the cord doesn't hinder cleaning in hard-to-reach areas.
【Ideal Gift for Your Family】Very sweet and warm gift for your family, saving the time and effectively relieves the bruden for daily housework. Homtronics specialized in home and kitchen items for many years. We are committed to providing more cleaning tools to help you and your family clean more easily.
【What Will You Get】1*Cordless Electric Spin Scrubber，Adjustable Handles(assembly required)，1* Fixed Hook，8* Replaceable Brush Heads，1*USB-C Cable，1* Storage bag, 1* Instruction

8.7

Excellent

We scanned 1878 products

We reviewed these offers relevant to the Electric Spin Scrubber within online retailers such as Amazon, eBay and other local retailers, ensuring we covered all major brands and models. The products we selected come from trusted brands like Leebein, YKYI, NBONEBS, keimi, PKBD, Homtronics, all of which have a reputation for consistently delivering high-quality products that users love and innovative approaches for function & design.

For the best Electric Spin Scrubber in the market, we considered we took a deep dive into 9391 online reviews , focusing on elements like user satisfaction, performance in real-world conditions, and long-term reliability. Our ranking also evaluates each review’s relevancy, authenticity, up-to-dateness and depth so that the comparison is more sound.

We concluded that:

The clear winner of our analysis is Leebein Electric Spin Scrubber, Shower Scrubber with 4 Adjustable Angles and 8 Brush Heads, Electric Scrubber with Long Handle & Remote Controller, Cleaning Brush for Bathroom, Tub, Floor (Black). We love many things about this product by Leebein. What sets it apart from the competition is Effortless deep cleaning capability, Revolutionary remote control function, Long-lasting fast charge tech.
The best value product for most shoppers and where user satisfaction is continuously the highest is Leebein Electric Spin Scrubber, 2025 New Cordless Cleaning Brush Bathroom Scrubber, IPX7 Waterproof Shower Scrubber with 7 Brush Heads, Extendable Long Handle and 2 Speeds Scrubber for Bathtub Floor by Leebein based on online reviews by bloggers, experts and online shoppers.
The biggest bargain at the moment for Electric Spin Scrubber and the best cost-to-value ratio is Electric Spin Scrubber, Cordless Cleaning Brush with 5 Replaceable Brush Heads and 2H Power Dual Speed, Adjustable & Detachable Long Handle, Shower Scrubber for Bathroom Tub Tile Floor Car, White-CA.at NBONEBS with a 88% discount.
Our list of the best Electric Spin Scrubber is updated regularly to reflect new releases and changes in product availability, so be sure to check back often for the latest rankings and discounts.

10 Best Electric Spin Scrubber in Canada

Related Deals You Might Like for Electric Spin Scrubber

Depcler Electric Spin Scrubber with 4000mAh Battery, 380-500 RPM, 8 Replaceable Brush Heads, Adjustable Handle for Bathroom, Kitchen & Floor Cleaning

NanoMin 13 in 1 Electric Spin Scrubber, Power Electric Cleaning Brush with Extension Handle, Bathroom Accessories Set with 11 Replaceable Brushes for Toilet, Tub, Kitchen, Floor

Electric Spin Scrubber, [IPX8 Waterproof] Homtronics Cordless Electric Cleaning Brush with 4 Replaceable Brush Head, 120cm Adjustable Long Handle for Bathroom, Kitchen, Home, Black

SAKAKI Electric Spin Scrubber Cordless Shower Cleaning Brush with 10 Replaceable Heads Powerful IPX7 Waterproof Bathroom Cleaner 3 Speeds Detachable Long Handle Voice Broadcast for Floor Car Kitchen

Electric Spin Scrubber, Cordless Cleaning Brush with 8 Replaceable Heads. 2 Adjustable Speeds Power Scrubber Brush for Bathroom Tub, Floor, Car, Kitchen. Unique Gift for Women Wife Grandma Friend

600RPM Electric Spin Scrubber, BIUBLE 2024 New Cordless Cleaning Brush with Adjustable Long Handle, 5 Upgrade Replaceable Brush Heads, Bathroom Shower Cleaning Scrubber for Bathtub Grout Tile Floor

Electric Spin Scrubber for Cleaning, Bathroom Cleaning Brushes with 8 Replaceable Heads, 3 Adjustable Speeds Power Scrubber 3000mAh Rechargeable Battery Electric Handheld Brush for Bathtub Tile Floor

Electric Spin Scrubber - [IPX8 Waterproof] Homtronics Cordless Cleaning Brush with 4 Brush Heads, 2 Speed Mode, 120cm Adjustable Handle for Bathroom/Kitchen

SYNOSHI Electric Spin Scrubber, Power Cleaning Brush with 3 Heads, Cordless Waterproof Shower Scrubber with Dual Speed, Perfect for Cleaning Bathroom, Tile, Cars, Floor. Electric Scrub Brush for tub

Electric Spin Scrubber for Cleaning Bathroom, Shower Scrubber Cordless Cleaning Brush with IPX7 Waterproof & 2 Speed, 3 Brush Heads, Bathroom Cleaning Supplies for Shower Tub Kitchen Tile Toilet White

We scanned 1878 products

We concluded that: